Jun 18, 2012

Changes In Causes Of Disability

     This is from the Social Security Advisory Board's Aspects of Disability: Decision Making: Data and Materials.As with many of these charts, it can be read in different ways. One can certainly note the dramatic increase in disability based upon mental illness. However, I would submit that this has far more to do with the dramatic changes wrought in psychiatry by the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM) than by anything intrinsic to Social Security. If you're not familiar with the DSM, it's probably the biggest development in the history of psychiatry. It's the Bible of psychiatry. While there are plenty of critics of individual portions of the DSM, I think that few people deny that it has been a dramatically positive development. If you are outraged by this increase in the number of people found disabled due to psychiatric illness, be careful to note the dramatic drop in disability benefits awarded due to circulatory disorders -- mostly heart disease. This is also due to developments in medicine, in this case cardiology. You can't take one type of improvement in medicine without taking the other types of improvement in medicine. 
     My best guesses are that the increase in musculoskeletal approvals has to do with the aging of the population and, perhaps, to different coding at Social Security. I don't think there has actually been much change in Social Security policies or practices in evaluating musculoskeletal disorders. 

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

it's interesting that musculoskeltal is on the rise. i would have expected that to be dropping. the cancer line is also interesting. i would have expected that to be very consistent.

Anonymous said...

did someone say pay down the backlog???

Anonymous said...

Actually, I beleive with the ready access to MRI's and the influx of people over the age of 50, it is very natural to see an increase in back disorder, discogenic and degenerative. Furtehr, when the economy was good and there were good union jobs, people would work with some pain and now they have no jobs so their pain and depression increase.. Downward cycle..

Anonymous said...

4:40 is on the right track, and I've seen a significant amount of people who fit that description.

unfortunately, 2:09 is also correct.