According to a recent study 54% of Americans between the ages of 16 and 74 read below the equivalent of a sixth grade education.
Why does this matter for Social Security? That 54% account for the vast majority of disability claims, particularly those disability claims which are most likely to generate appeals. The thing is that if you develop serious health problems, you have something to fall back on if you become disabled if you've got good mental abilities. If you're a fire fighter, for instance, and your knees give out but you're not too old, you may be able to switch to being a 911 operator, for instance, because you have a little background in the field and you probably have enough intellectual ability to learn a new job. However, if you're a roofer, you may not be able to make the transition to being a roofing estimator, for instance, because you may not have the innate intellectual ability. (I'm sure there are plenty of smart roofers but it's hard, dangerous work with poor pay so who do you think ends up in these jobs, for the most part? Did you think people take roofing jobs simply because they like working outside?) Add in increased age, which reduces adaptability, and switching to work with fewer physical demands but requiring more intellectual ability becomes extremely difficult. Don't think that age makes a difference in adaptability? You're almost certainly young. Wait until you're older. You'll understand.
There are those on the right who honestly believe that way too many people are approved for Social Security disability, that those people may have some health problems but that they could easily switch to less demanding jobs if it wasn't so easy to get Social Security disability benefits. Well, it's not at all easy to get Social Security disability benefits nor is it easy for most of the workforce to switch to less physically demanding jobs.
DEMS tend to be more educated and support disability and other social programs. Yet the recipients tend to be more Republican (my personal observation). What irony!
ReplyDeleteI think the word you are looking for is compassion.
Delete@12:04 AGREED! I just wanted to mention, roofing isn't a low paying job. It's hard work in sometimes very harsh conditions. I've seen some pretty well off roofers! I know it was just an example, and you're absolutely right, roofing is WAY different than estimation. If one only has the intellect for blue collar jobs, switching to a white collar job could be impossible. I'm met some very smart people out there that can do amazing things! Give them a form to fill out, and they scoff at it like it's their archenemy!
ReplyDeleteAre DI applicants required to take a literacy test? Should they be?
ReplyDeleteThe lack of society-wide literacy claimed in this article seems like a much, much bigger problem than its implications for disability.
This is an incredibly classist view of blue-collar workers. Roofing is hard work; however it is not simple. People don't go to college or trade schools for many reasons, not just because they lack the "innate intellectual ability" to do other work. As well the ability to read is not a direct indication of intellectual ability. For someone who claims to advocate for individuals with disabilities, you should know better and do better.
ReplyDeleteNot surprisng
ReplyDelete