Social Security Bulletin Out

The Social Security Administration has released the November 2008 issue of the Social Security Bulletin, a mostly statistical publication. This issue contains a technical article co-authored by Andrew Biggs, who had earlier worked at Social Security where he was a huge promoter of privatization of Social Security.

TMS For Depression -- It's Coming

Those who have much involvement with the Social Security Administration know that the primary work of the agency is adjudicating disability claims. Depression is an incredibly important element in producing disability. It may be the most commonly encountered illness in disability claims. Depression is often the primary cause of depression and is even more common as a complication to the treatment of physical illness or as a cause of somatization. Often, depression is so intertwined with a claimant's other health problems that it is impossible to say how much of the person's disability is due to depression and how much is due to other illnesses.

Any new treatment for depression is potentially quite important to Social Security. On October 8, 2008 the Food and Drug Administration approved Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) as a treatment for depression.

Here is a description of TMS from Wikipedia:

TMS is simply the application of the principle of induction to get electrical current across the insulating tissues of the scalp and skull without discomfort. A coil of wire, encased in plastic, is held to the head. When the coil is energized by the rapid discharge of a large capacitor, a rapidly changing current flows in its windings. This produces a magnetic field oriented orthogonally to the plane of the coil. The magnetic field passes unimpeded through the skin and skull, inducing an oppositely directed current in the brain that flows tangentially with respect to skull. The current induced in the structure of the brain activates nearby nerve cells in much the same way as currents applied directly to the cortical surface.

Unlike Electro-Convulsive Therapy (ECT), TMS does not require anesthesia. There are far fewer side effects. It appears that TMS could be easily used routinely by psychiatrists. It will take time to tell if this will be used only rarely, as is the case with ECT, but anything that holds out hope for those suffering from depression, especially those who do not respond to medication is important.

Biggs In Wall Street Journal

Andrew Biggs, formerly the Deputy Commissioner of Social Security (on a recess appointment, after the Senate refused to consider his nomination) has a piece in today's Wall Street JournalWants Social Security To Be A Welfare Plan." claiming that "Obama Of course, in a larger sense Social Security has always been a "welfare plan" in the sense that it is intended to promote the welfare of the American people. The widespread belief that Social Security does promote the welfare of the American people is why the American people support Social Security, a point which Biggs has never understood.

Biggs' article, like everything else that I have read by him, is almost incomprehensible. His thesis, as best I can tell, is that because Barack Obama wants to cut income taxes on the poor and middle class while increasing the FICA tax on high income earners that somehow Social Security will become a dreaded "welfare program." As best I can tell, any increase in the progressivity of taxation in the United States is "welfare" to Biggs. I guess the word "Welfare" sounds more frightening to Biggs than "Socialism", the other term being thrown around by the McCain campaign to describe Obama's plan to increase progressivity of taxation. All Biggs is doing is coupling statistics of dubious relevance with a ridiculous argument and using a pejorative term to describe his opponent's plan.

Union Upset With Astrue

Below is an e-mail which I just received from James Marshall of the American Federation of Government Employees, which has attached to it two e-mail which he recently sent to Commissioner Astrue:

I know you are quite interested in Social Security matters and I believe you have a blog where you post various information concerning Social Security news. I am also aware that Commissioner Astrue has not kept his commitments made during his confirmation process that he would work with the employees' union in addressing the disability backlog, as well as other problems facing the Agency. I have pasted two e-mails below that I sent to Commissioner Astrue this month regarding the Agency's Strategic Plan and the barriers we will be facing due to the continuing resolution and shortfalls in funding and staff this fiscal year. I also noted that Deputy Commissioner de Soto and/or Chief Administrative Law Judge Cristaudo have not even met with me to discuss how we can work together to eliminated the hearing backlog and improve the overall processing of disability claims and the quality of such decisions. For the record, I have been employed by the Social Security Administration for 50 years and the Office of Disability Adjudication and Review (formerly Office of Hearings and Appeals) for 36 of those years and believe I can provide constructive input regarding the Agency's failures in eliminating the disability backlog in a more timely manner, improving employee morale and other critical issues facing the Office of Disability Adjudication and Review.

While I speak for approximately 5,000 ODAR employees, their constructive input to me has remained with me because the Agency's leadership does not wish to hear from its dedicated and outstanding employees as to how the Agency's quick fix changes are not the answer to decrease the backlog and improve quality of service. You may post this e-mail to your blog and/or question Commissioner Astrue directly as to his negativity towards AFGE which obviously affected the American people we serve.

James E. Marshall
Acting Spokesperson, AFGE General Committee and President, AFGE Council 215


From: Marshall, James
Sent: Wednesday, October 22, 2008 9:37 AM
To: Astrue, Michael J.
Subject: Pre-Senator Baucus (Strategic Plan FY 2008 - FY 2013 and FY 2009 CR)
Importance: High
Sensitivity: Confidential

Commissioner Astrue:
I note that approximately two weeks have elapsed since I sent the e-mail below to you without a response from you or any other individual in the Agency. Prior to referring this matter to Senator Baucus, as well as several other Congressional leaders, I am giving you a second opportunity as the head of the Agency to demonstrate some type of working relationship with AFGE, noting we represent over 40,000 Social Security employees. I still find it extremely difficult to understand why you have such reluctance to work with us to meet the challenges this Agency faces now and will face over the next several years. As you are fully aware, I have been extremely disappointed in the attitudes of Deputy Commissioner de Soto and Chief Administrative Law Judge Cristaudo in that neither of these individuals has met with me and/or has had the common courtesy to be responsive to me regarding a multitude of issues, as well as suggestions, many of which I believe would improve the overall processing of disability claims.

I would appreciate a timely response to this e-mail or I will proceed accordingly in the representation of the outstanding Federal employees who I represent.

James E. Marshall
Acting Spokesperson, AFGE General Committee and President, AFGE Council 215

From: Marshall, James
Sent: Thursday, October 09, 2008 11:48 AM
To: Astrue, Michael J.
Cc: Alfonzo, Carmen; Ennis, Cynthia; 'Ennis, Cynthia'; Fredericksen, Deborah; 'Fredericksen. Debbie'; Joseph, Agatha; Sipple, Cindy O.; Skayne, Susan; Tucker, Earl; 'witold1@attglobal.net'; Hicks, Cathy; Armet, James

Subject: Strategic Plan FY 2008 - FY 2013 and FY 2009 CR
Importance: High
Sensitivity: Confidential

Good Morning Commissioner Astrue:

On behalf of the AFGE General Committee, I am submitting this e-mail in response to your e-mail broadcast dated September 24, 2008, to all SSA and DDS employees regarding Agency Strategic Plan FY 2008 - FY 2013. At the outset, AFGE notes that in your letter, you indicated that this plan had been developed in part by conferring with our unions which we presume meant AFGE was included. To our knowledge, the only contact that the General Committee had with the Agency regarding the Strategic Plan was a slideshow with notice that if we had comments they should be submitted in writing within 10 days of the slideshow. Unfortunately, we were unable to meet such mandated time frames for submission of any comments and thought that we would subsequently have the opportunity to sit down with you and your executive staff and have a full and open dialogue regarding the Agency's goals. It appears that again, our thoughts and vision for the future SSA have been buried without being heard. Shame on someone because as the representative of over 40,000 employees in this Agency, their voices should be heard through us, especially since they are the most outstanding Federal employees of any Agency.

We recognize that for FY 2009, there will be significant barriers to meet goals because of the continuing resolution and shortfalls in funding and staff. Having said that, we would have thought you would have arranged a meeting with the General Committee to discuss these shortfalls and how we can work together to eliminate the hearing backlog and to improve the overall processing of disability claims and the quality of such decisions, as well as improving all other services for our retirees. To allow the progress in our attempts to meet such challenges over the past several years to erode like the stock market, is unconscionable and you as the Commissioner should embrace the General Committee leadership for the American public we serve to ensure that such erosion does not occur. I await your response on behalf of the General Committee for a face to face meeting with you, your executive staff and our AFGE General Committee leadership.

In closing, please be advised that I, as the President of AFGE Council 215 representing ODAR employees, have yet to have any meeting with Deputy Commissioner de Soto and/or Chief Administrative Law Judge Cristaudo since they been in their positions.

Rosasco Impressed By Astrue

Troy Rosasco, a member of the Board of Directors of the National Organization of Social Security Claimants Representatives (NOSSCR), met Commisioner Astrue at the pool while attending the recent NOSSCR Conference in Los Angeles and came away impressed, writing in his blog that "This is a very bright guy, and in my opinion he is moving the agency in the right direction."

The Transition Approaches

Paul Light, professor of Public Service at New York University, recently spoke at the Library of Congress about the upcoming transition to a new President. Here is a bit of the summary of the talk given by Tom Shoop at FedBlog:

The upcoming change of administrations "will be the most difficult transition since Abraham Lincoln," he said. Even Franklin Roosevelt at least had more time to begin planning to address the effects of the Great Depression (his inauguration wasn't until March 4, 1933) and didn't have to deal with two wars overseas.

And here is some detail on what the two candidates transition plans from Sam Stein at the Huffington Post:

As the 2008 campaign nears its conclusion, the presidential transition efforts of the two major candidates have become a study in contrasts: Sen. Barack Obama has organized an elaborate well-staffed network to prepare for his possible ascension to the White House, while Sen. John McCain has all but put off such work until after the election. ...

[O]ne official with direct knowledge, who spoke on the condition of anonymity, expressed concern with McCain's approach. The Arizona Senator has instructed his team to not spend time on the transition effort, according to the source, both out of a desire to have complete focus on winning the election as well as a superstitious belief that the campaign shouldn't put the cart before the horse. ...

With 100 or so days before the next president takes office, Obama's transition effort has been organized into roughly a dozen teams of six to eight people to plot out the approach for each agency, according to a Democratic official. ...

The president and CEO of the Center for American Progress, former White House chief of staff John Podesta, is reportedly heading up Obama's transition team.

Mostly A Win For UNUM

Remember that qui tam (or whistle blower) lawsuit claiming that UNUM was doing something abusive by forcing the people to whom it was paying long term disability benefits to file claims for Social Security disability benefits? It's over and UNUM mostly won. Here are some excerpts from UNUM's press release:

A news release issued this morning by Washington law firm Phillips & Cohen LLP claiming victory in a trial against Unum regarding Social Security Claims is misleading and filled with inaccuracies. [It looks like Philiips & Cohen has taken the press release off its website.] The jury actually sided with Unum on the majority of claims. The two claims that were decided in favor of the plaintiff resulted in a total award of less than $3,000. ...

As part of the trial, Unum produced 1,600 claim files that the plaintiffs then narrowed down to 101 claims that they said should not have been submitted to the Social Security Administration. This number was later reduced to 61 as it was revealed that many of these claims were actually awarded Social Security disability benefits, and in other instances there was no proof that an application was ever made to the government.

To put these numbers in perspective, Unum processed nearly 400,000 disability claims and paid more than $4 billion in disability benefits in 2007. ...

“Of the two remaining claims decided in favor of the plaintiff, we continue to believe they have no merit and we think we will ultimately prevail upon appeal,” Collins added.

I have no love for UNUM but this lawsuit just seemed ridiculous to me.

Someone Notices That Astrue Is Stretching The Truth

Alex Wayne has written an article in Congressional Quarterly (subscription required) that points out that while Michael Astrue, Commissioner of Social Security, is saying is saying that his agency is making progress on the backlog of disability claims awaiting a hearing, in truth, those backlogs have gotten measurably worse over the last year. A spokesman for Social Security could only make the argument that there was improvement because things were getting worse at a slower rate than they used to. Even this "improvement" is probably due to the fact that the agency has gotten a larger budget than President Bush and Commissioner Astrue asked for.

You may never have read Congressional Quarterly, but, trust me, it is an important publication. CQ is required reading for many in Congress and higher levels of government. No one else comes close to covering Washington the way CQ does. Issues that first appear in Congressional Quarterly are often picked up by the popular media. By the way, despite the name, Congressional Quarterly is published daily and e-mail updates throughout the day are available.

Update: The article is now available at CQ's free site.