Sep 13, 2010

Dessert Is Ibuprofen

From today's New York Times:
At the Cooper Tire plant in Findlay, Ohio, Jack Hartley, who is 58, works a 12-hour shift assembling tires: pulling piles of rubber and lining over a drum, cutting the material with a hot knife, lifting the half-finished tire, which weighs 10 to 20 pounds, and throwing it onto a rack.

Mr. Hartley performs these steps nearly 30 times an hour, or 300 times in a shift. “The pain started about the time I was 50,” he said. “Dessert with lunch is ibuprofen. Your knees start going bad, your lower back, your elbows, your shoulders.”

He said he does not think he can last until age 66, when he will be eligible for full Social Security retirement benefits. At 62 or 65, he said, “that’s it.”

After years of debate about how to keep Social Security solvent, the White House has created an 18-member panel to consider changes, including raising the retirement age. Representative John A. Boehner, Republican of Ohio and the House minority leader, has called for raising the age as high as 70 in the next 20 years, and many Democrats have endorsed similar steps, against opposition from some liberal groups. The panel will report by Dec. 1, after the midterm elections. ...

A new analysis by the Center for Economic and Policy Research found that one in three workers over age 58 does a physically demanding job like Mr. Hartley’s — including hammering nails, bending under sinks, lifting baggage — that can be radically different at age 69 than at age 62. Still others work under difficult conditions, like exposure to heat or cold, exposure to contaminants or weather, cramped workplaces or standing for long stretches.

In all, the researchers found that 45 percent of older workers, or 8.5 million, held such difficult jobs. For janitors, nurses’ aides, plumbers, cashiers, waiters, cooks, carpenters, maintenance workers and others, raising the retirement age may mean squeezing more out of a declining body.

I have clients who perform that tire building job -- except they are making truck tires. Can you imagine how heavy that work is? I am told that it is rare for an employees to make it to 65 at that plant.

3 comments:

Gordon Gates said...

Did you notice that, either in the article itself or the published comments so far, there is no discussion at all of Social Security disability?

Workers in this age group who become unable to perform their labor-intensive jobs tend to take earlier retirement (and the accompanying 25% penalty) rather than apply for disability. Many are simply unaware that they would qualify for Social Security disability benefits.

Anonymous said...

I agree older workers will have more difficulty with physical work with passage of time. Also younger workers who have had significant history of illness will too.

But just because a person is advanced age or approaching advancing age they should not be grided in. This is partly why the ssa trust fund is nearly gone.

Anonymous said...

If you can no longer do the job you have been doing, get a different job. If there is no job you can handle due to medical reasons, file for disability. Being unable to do your usual job does not qualify you for disability. The taxpayers are not obligated to support those who have no inclination to attempt to overcome their circumstances.